top of page

David Payne and the Oklahoma Boomers

 

Oklahoma's creation wasn't easy
 

The transition from the Indian Territory to the Oklahoma Territory is deeply embedded in the first part of The Unassigned Lands and factored into much of Bud's and Angela's behavior.  It also factored into a great deal of America's political and social behavior in real life, so I went to a lot of trouble to keep it accurate in the book.  The challenge was the topic is insanely complex and it was difficult to cull the less relevant events from Bud's story without skewing the historical aspects too much.  (You'll have to be the judge of that).  This is a very brief synopsis and still leaves out a ton of interesting things (but, noone wants a 10,000 word web page).   My main source was Carl Coke Rister's Land Hunger: David L Payne And The Oklahoma Boomers.  Rister was a superb historian and Land Hunger is a must-read for anyone serious about Oklahoma's formation or David Payne's biography.  

​The story begins with America's westward expansion and the systematic removal of many Indian tribes into what is now the state of Oklahoma.  When the Civil War started, most tribes sided with the Confederacy in the hope that a divided U. S. might leave some room for them.  No luck, there. When the South was finally defeated, the North punished its adversaries and the Indian tribes got their own flavor of Reconstruction.  

All the tribes were forced to engage in the "sale" of their lands.  Whole reservations were divided, some tribes "buying" sections while being forced to "sell" their existing lands.  The only tribe (mostly) spared was The Cherokee Nation.  The Cherokees had renounced their treaty with the south at the last moment and were allowed to keep their lands on the condition that other tribes, displaced (again) from the "sale" of their territory were permitted to relocate there.

Years before, in 1862, Abraham Lincoln signed an important new law named The Homestead Act.  That law allowed any citizens over 21 to claim up to 160 acres of public land and keep it as long as they lived there for five years, improved the land, and paid a nominal filing fee.  The law was very popular with the public because, suddenly, nearly anyone could own land and millions of people became land owners. (The Homestead Act remained in effect until 1976 when the Federal Government decided that it would retain ownership of public lands, with the exception of parts of Alaska.  The last Homestead Act claim was proven there in 1984.)

The bureaucrats who oversaw the "sale" of the Indian lands either didn't consult a map or didn't care that the new boundaries left a considerable amount of land, right in the middle, unaccounted for.  Enter David Payne.  Payne was fully aware of the Homestead Act and contended that any land specifically excluded from Indian reservations must, by definition, be public land and subject to settlement under the terms of the Act. 

The federal government and the Indians disagreed, countering that the Indian Territory belonged to the Indians regardless of what the internal boundaries between tribes might be.  The "unassigned lands" (which would become the official name of that district) was not public land and not subject to settlement.  Period.

Payne created an organization named The Oklahoma Colony which was dedicated to opening the Unassigned Lands, selling both shares of ownership and membership.  His members became known as the Oklahoma Boomers, which would eventually be the term applied to anyone settling in Oklahoma.   Payne maintained that when The Unassigned Lands finally opened his Colony would ensure an orderly settlement and he was fond of claiming that the first church and school would be operating within the first week.  The Colony and its members would apply political pressure to open the land and Payne was certain it was only a matter of time.

Payne was, at that point, unaware of his second adversary: the cattle lobby.  (click HERE to learn how cattle played a role in shaping the southwest).  During the Civil War, the unmanaged cattle herds in Texas and New Mexico grew to enormous levels.  After the war, a sturdy new creature dubbed a 'cowboy' emerged.  Cowboys would gather the wild cattle, brand them, and drive them north, through the Indian Territory, to the rail heads in Kansas where they were sold and shipped back east.

The cattlemen made grazing deals with the Indians in order to fatten the herds before selling them in Kansas.  Those deals were fantastically profitable to the cattlemen and breaking up the Indian Territory would be a terrible setback for them.  Thus, the cattle lobby began using some of its profits to influence Congress to keep the Indian Territory exactly as it was.  Thus, despite Payne's and The Oklahoma Colony's lobbying, nothing happened.

Payne pivoted.  He announced that he would stage an 'invasion' of the Unassigned Lands where he and his Boomers would make claims.  His unannounced goal was to be arrested and brought before a federal judge where he could make his case that the land was public and available for settlement.  If the government wouldn't act, the courts might.  

People flooded to the Kansas border to join in Payne's invasion, alarming the Feds who dispatched the Army to the border. Payne acknowledged the stalemate and left for Texas to visit relatives.  While he was gone, President Hayes foolishly wrote that he believed the Indian Territory should be opened, which called Payne back to the border to announce another invasion.

He pulled it off that time.  He and a handful of Boomers evaded the army and staked claims along the Canadian River, then sent a message back to The Kansas City Times, which which was printed, proclaiming the Oklahoma Lands to be settled. 

The Army eventually found him, but Payne was able to convince the lieutenant in charge that he really was on public land and the army had no standing to remove him.  The squad departed only to be replaced a few days later by a different officer who didn't care.   Payne and his Boomers were arrested and taken to Ft. Reno where they complained loudly, to no avail.  They were then herded back to Kansas, but just as the approached the border something odd happened.

A scout came racing in with a message for the lieutenant in command: Make camp immediately, do not return to Kansas until further notice.  It was eventually discovered that a Kansas judge had issued a writ of habeus corpus to be served on the officer holding Payne and his Boomers.  The army had delayed in order to prevent the officer from being forced into a Kansas courtroom.

That began a cycle of people gathering at the border, regardless of season or the weather, whenever Payne announced another invasion.  He and William Couch, his right-hand man, made good on several other attempts.  In one crucial episode he and his Boomers founded a town, Rock Falls, where they prepared defenses and actually had the ability to repel the army.  The colonel in charge entered the town and informed Payne (and everyone else) that they were about to get the gunfight they'd been spoiling for.  That unnerved many Boomers, who elected to leave (with the army's blessing) until the Boomers were forced to concede.

They were arrested again, but this time they were sent to Ft. Smith, Arkansas, to appear in Judge Isaac Parker's court.  Once again, the army dodged and delayed in order to avoid being served by a judge.  Meanwhile, the prisoners were treated very poorly. By the time the crafty deputy snuck into camp and served the colonel in charge, Payne and the others were in bad shape.

The colonel ignored the summons, infuriating the Kansas judge who'd issued it.  Payne was delivered to Ft. Smith where Parker took one look at the Boomers and released them all until the hearing several months hence.  When the hearing occurred, Payne was found guilty of multiple violations of the Indian Intercourse Act.  Unfortunately for the government, there was only one punishment permitted by the law - a 1000 dollar fine.  Payne didn't have the money or anything to confiscate, so Parker simply released him, setting an unfortunate precedent: Destitute Boomers (which was all of them) would be released.  The government's primary tool against the Boomers was useless.

​Payne was finally charged with something that allowed him to present his case that the Unassigned Lands were public and subject to settlement under the Homestead Act.  Judge Foster wrote a very difficult to read and legalistic decision that boiled down to Payne winning.  All charges against Boomers were dropped and an enormous celebration ensued.

Just 10 days later they endured a tragedy of equal magnitude: Payne suffered a heart attack and died during breakfast.  Couch took over, but Payne's death appears to be the tipping point where opposition to opening the lands began to dissipate.  Even one of Payne's most vocal antagonists, the editor of the Wichita Beacon, changed his mind and wrote a long editorial where he compared Payne to Daniel Boone's efforts in Kentucky.

Congress drug its feet, but Couch and The Colony kept up the pressure and, finally, were rewarded.  An election had happened and there would be considerable change in Congress, and several proposals were suddenly getting serious consideration.  Finally, William Springer from Illinois managed to add an amendment to that year's Indian Appropriation Bill allowing the president to open the Unassigned Lands at his convenience in a manner he deemed appropriate.

The bill was signed and the president deemed that high noon, on April 22nd, 1889, was convenient and the Unassigned Lands would be thrown open in a massive land run. A hundred thousand people lined the border, waiting for the moment.  When it came, there was chaos...in both good and bad ways.

The good part was the land was opened an many people were able to take claims.  The bad chaos was that a large number of people had snuck into the territory early and were already present, claims made, when the Boomers came speeding onto the scene. The Boomers dubbed the illegal entrants 'Sooners' and the process figuring out who owned what began.  Many cases were decided with gun fights.

The most egregious Sooners were the railroad men, surveyors, and deputy marshals who simply made a claim in advance (often more than one) and dared anyone to try and take it.  Unfortunately, they nearly universally got away with it.  (click HERE to learn about the corruption).  The deputy marshals were almost impossible to control and the government tried many adjustments in the next 3 openings to prevent their mischief.  The Sac-Fox, Arapahoe, and the massive Cherokee Strip runs all featured officials behaving badly.  Finally, the government gave up on the 'horse-race' style and changed to a lottery.

The Kiowa-Commanche-Apache opening prevented the deputies mischief, but was plagued by a different kind of Sooner - prospectors.  The Wichita Mountains were rumored to be rich in gold deposits and prospectors had been making illegal claims for years.  More gunfights. (see HERE for the Wichita Mountain gold rush).  That was the last major opening and represented the end of the cattle lobby's influence over Oklahoma.  (see HERE for the influence Cattle had, which was considerable).

 

​

landmarks.jpg
bottom of page